Opinions on common statement
What do you think of the statement, "Not being biologically related to a child doesn't make you any less of a parent. Being a real parent isn't in the dna, it's in the heart."?
I asked my DH what he thought and he just said he agreed. I asked him if he thought that you can be a parent to any child you want as long as it's in your heart, no matter how many obstacles there are? He said, yes, he thinks so. Then I just said that if he really thought about it and had specific examples I think he'd answer differently, but ok.
What I wanted to say was, "so you could be a parent to a child that was unruly, didn't behave, was rude, mean to your other kids, already has 2 parents and doesn't want another one, and shows no interest in a relationship with you?" because that's how it is with my SS7 that everyone thinks I should love like my own and be a parent for. IMO I have been more of a parent to SS than anyone. I just admit that I don't love him like I love my own.
I definitely believe you can be a parent to an adopted child, or even some sort of parent to a stepchild especially if their bio is not in the picture, but my situation is so different from that. I think people expect way too much. I thought my DH understood but maybe he doesn't.
- Countrymom's blog
- Log in or register to post comments
Comments
I think 'parent' is not just
I think 'parent' is not just a biological term, but also a socially-constructed term. By that I mean, it's a role that has a place in society; being a parent is not just a biological fact. Even the use of the term 'real' in the original statement pretty much says that too.
So I think that becoming or being a parent is a lot more than biological material, or marriage, or adoption, or any thing like that. And if you are dealing with a child that is poorly behaved *without* the authority to intervene, then I don't see how you are a parent. You can love, sure, but love is just the thread that keeps relationships going when everyone's being a dick. If you have nothing else, then you just have a bunch of dicks sitting around pissing each other off until someone dies or moves out.
I agree with the statement. I
I agree with the statement. I look at it as being a parent is in your heart. The statement says nothing about loving that child just that you are a parent at heart.
People can have all the love for a child but be the crappiest parent because they are too self involved to put another human being before their own needs. I do not think a step-parent has to love a child at all because lets face it some kids make that next to impossible to do. But if they are in your home in under your roof if you are a parent at heart you will still try to parent that kid a little.
Maybe I am off taking it that way just how I see it.
I also like it because it confirms that DNA and biology does not mean crap. Being an egg donor or sperm donor does not make anyone a parent.
I think biology means
I think biology means nothing, in that many people can have sex and deliver a baby and be shit parents or neglect the child completely. I understand their is generally a "bond" when you gaze into your newborn's eyes after the delivery but it is NOT that way for everyone across the board.
As far as loving the step kid who has 2 parents "like your own"... that is different. They don't "need" your love (an adopted child who had no parents would need your love. A stepkid who's mother died or abandoned them would likely need your love).
In the case of a skid with 2 active parents, your "love" is just a bonus, really. Just respecting them would be enough.
"Not being biologically
"Not being biologically related to a child doesn't make you any less of a parent. Being a real parent isn't in the dna, it's in the heart."?
Barf - that's what I think about it.
I think there is "parent" as a noun and "parent" as a verb.
I HATE the whole "love them as your own" crap. Why would I love random kids to whom I am not related?
Ugh..
Exactly!
Exactly!
I believe it might be true
I believe it might be true for some people, especially in the case of adoption, but I agree that you can "parent" a child without being a parent. I mean... parenting as a verb, yeah, I do that all day every day. But loving a child more than I love myself - enough that i'd die for them? Nope. I don't do that lol. And that, to me, is part of being a parent.
I'm only 7 weeks along in pregnancy and I love whatever my baby is right now more than I love my stepdaughter, and that's okay. It's a good thing she's got two parents who SHOULD feel the same for her. my DH does but BM definitely doesn't, and that's not something I feel the need to make up for anymore. I love my stepdaughter but nothing like I will love my own in 7.5 months time <3
I looked up the actual
I looked up the actual definition of parent: "noun - a father or mother, birth/biological parent, adoptive parent, foster parent, step parent, guardian. verb - be or act as a mother or father to someone, bring up, look after, take care of."
According to the definition and what you all say, I am a parent in every sense of the word, to my own and to SS, but I guess what bothers me is I know a lot of people refer to this as loving them like your own, that they don't have to be biologically yours to love them like their "real parents". I in no way love SS like my own, I'm still trying to just like him, he has 2 parents that love him (even if they don't show it well) and my girls have me and their father.
In a sense of someone raising
In a sense of someone raising a child as their own such as adopting them of course they are real parents. My brother and SIL adopted my nephew and he is just as much their son as my biological nephew. They are his parents in every sense of the word.
Sorry, but I disagree with
Sorry, but I disagree with this. The stigma society places on stepparents to "love the kids as your own" is unfair. Nobody sits the children down and puts a demand on them to love the stepparent just the same as their mother or father. Because that's impossible. You're not there to be another parent. You're there to support your spouse while they parent their own kids. That said, you should treat your spouse's kids with kindness and be a support to them in times when it's needed. Form your own bond with them on terms that are acceptable to both you and the kids. But inserting yourself in the children's lives as a parental figure when they have two parents is wrong. You're not the parent.
Also, my DH agrees with me on this.
I think it can be true for
I think it can be true for some people but it is not true for all. You don't have to be biologically related to a child to be a parent to that child. But just because there is a child in your life on a regular (daily? 50/50? EOWE? etc) basis doesn't mean you automatically become a parent.
I love my nephews and my
I love my nephews and my niece very much but I am not their parent. It's just not the same. And when kids were younger I used to see them daily (living arrangements we had with my brothers family ), yet I never claimed to be their parent. You can love children yet not be a parent. My mom was always involved with grandkids, but she didn't pretend to be a parent
As about stepparents. I expect my DH to treat my DD nicely and kindly but love her or be a parent, that would be unfair expectation
This actually made me
This actually made me chuckle. I frequently take my niece and 2 nephews out. Woman with noooo kids. They always behave and i would rarely have a problem.
One day the 4 of us had to go grocery shopping. I was feeling a little under the weather. The 12 year old read the list and the 9 and 6 year olds found the items in the aisle. When we went through check out i let them pick out a piece of candy for being a team. They said thank you. Each carried a grocery bag without being asked. The cashier complimented them on "my children" being so well behaved and having mammers. I smiled and thanked her. My niece and nephews asked me why i didnt tell the cashier i was the aunt. I told them they were so good i wished they were my kids. My youngest nephew asked "what if we were bad". I laughed and said thats when i tell them I'm the aunt!
Yes it's possible as you as
Yes it's possible as you as the non biological parent is allowed to teach and discipline children, regardless