If there is a HELL, I fear I am going there....
Hi, ST....been gone for a while, busy at work. I come in need of some confession time. On Sunday, H receives text from BM that her father is gravely ill and she wants SD14 (we are custodial parents) to come see him before he passes. SD14 is at friend's house for weekend. H and I discuss it and he asks me if SD14 should go. I tell him that SD14 and I discussed her grandpa about a month prior when we first learned of his illness and SD14 said she hadn't seen the man in over 4 years and didn't have a distinct memory of him other than that he smoked a lot and had a nickname for her that she couldn't pronounce. So H and I decide to let SD14 decide what she wants to do. H asked me to talk to SD14 b/c lately she gives him lip lip and more lip.
Fast forward Sunday evening I ask SD14 to come home an hour early and we talk. I tell her this is your decision what do you want to do. She asked what I thought (she thinks so highly of me and my advice So I told her: you are a week away from high school, in which you will have to fight every second to stay ahead as you are still functioning on a 5th grade level (she asked to be mainstreamed/taken out of special ed program), you say you didn't have a relationship with him and you want to remember him in a healthier state...I believe those are compelling, mature considerations and I'll support you if you decide you don't want to go. And that was the decision she made.
Now herein lies the problem. I could have easily persuaded her otherwise. It's what I do for a living. And we got a text from SD18 her grandfather passed at 3.40 a.m. I feel horrible and guilty and like I'm going straight to hell or will die alone and lonely.
When my H asked my advice I disclaimed as follows: I am persuaded heavily by my illwill towards BM. From what you have told me, this man supposedly sexually molested BM for 9 years. But according to BM you supposedly raped her. If this man did that from the time she was 3 until 12, why is she making such a big deal about SD14 being there to hold his hand. I also told him that I didn't believe for one second BM was sex'y molested by her dad, just as I know for a fact H didn't rape her. So I told him I had a ton of sympathy for the dying father but none for BM. I also told H, look my dislike of BM is clouding my judgment ad affecting my advice.
In the end, they both listened to me and she didn't go see him. But now I am having grave regrets. I called my mom on Sunday for advice and she said, if the child wants to go, let her go. But what my mom doesn't get is that I could have swayed the child one way or another. I chose the sounds like you don't want to go path out of spite and hatred????
Some context, SD14 hasn't seen BM since November. SD14 has asked not to see BM as she is "so angry" at BM, but I have a lot to do with that also. SD14 has asked me a lot of questions and I am honest with her about everything. She was kept in the dark about so much but I don't believe in that. Problem is she wouldn't be so angry if I followed my H's lead and just pretended the world was great filled with great great people. Example: she says things like...you are so concerned about my biokid's safety, happiness, etc., that's how real moms are supposed to be, huh EvilDiva? To which I say, I believe as parents we have an obligation to ensure our children are x,y and z. To which she'll say, my mom only cares about herself and only uses us to get something for herself. Or she'll ask, did H cheat on BM? And I told her to ask H. She goes, I am asking you b/c you said you'd never lie to me. People treat me like I'll break if I get bad news. So I told her, no he did not. She also tells me constantly, it's shameful that everyone walks around pretending H is my biodad when anybody with eyes can tell he's not.
So she is angry at BM about a lot and I don't try to dissuade her of that anger. I don't preach forgiveness. I preach accountability. But is this the right thing to do?
A little about SD14...she is "borderline" mentally challenged and takes on others' problems, personalities, etc. She has very little impulse control that we work on. She has low self esteem, which we are working on. She never use to stand up for herself, but gosh have I fixed that problem, much to H's dismay. She has really evolved into a hard working little terror. She speaks up for herself and is finding her voice. I was selfish about seeing her grandpa b/c I felt if she did, she would spiral into one of her dark, deep depressions that she hasn't suffered in over 2 years. I didn't want to have to deal with that and try to get her off to a good start in HS, so I "helped" her along in her decision not to visit the grandfather.
I am sure that I am going to hell b/c isn't there a saying...the road to hell is paved with good intentions?
EvilDiva
- EvilDiva's blog
- Log in or register to post comments
Comments
one more thing
until about 1.5 years ago, SD14 would scratch huge 1 inch in diameter holes in her scalp and pull her hair out after visiting BM due to the drama that involved. She would also rub her hands together until they bled. We purposely alienated her from BM once we put it togethr that her neuroses only surfaced after being around BM. This was also a swaying factor for me.
Additionally when BM's mom died 2 or 3 years ago, BM would pick up the girls middle of the morn and race to CO, return the girls 2 days later crying upset only to get a call saying grandma is all better. This went on for a year. SD14 was a wreck during that; so I just didn't want her to go through something like that again.
After all of this however, bottom line is I am not convinced I would have taken the same path bvut for my deepseated disdain of BM.
Evil Diva
I can understand
why you feel guilty...I would also. I think I would also be questioning why i gave the advice I did. BUT I think it was best for sd in the end due to all the drama that may have followed. Yes, you could have talked her into going but ultimately in my opinion you did what you thought was right for her by taking the stance of,"well you didn't know him and etc..." I don't think you made the choice based on your feelings about bm...I think you made the choice based on your concern for sd. That's just how i see it based on reading your post.
I am proud of you that you are able to see that SOME decision are biased due to your disdain for her bm I just don't think it was the case in this situation. Takes a smart cookie to realize sometimes your judgment may be clouded by feelings,kudos doll!
The thing that impresses me most about America is the way parents obey their children. ~Edward, Duke of Windsor, Look, 5 March 1957
Suggestion
First of all, you may have protected her from some serious drama or possibly kept her from slipping into another mental state of harming herself. So instead of feeling guilty, try to see that it wasn't only your own personally feelings about BM and her family that were at work here...you obviously have concern for your SD also.
How about this...you and DH take SD (just the three of you...NO BM) to the grave of her grandfather. Let her say her goodbyes. Bring flowers, teddy bear...something she can leave. Let her grieve (tears or not). That's closure and she needs that, and it sounds like maybe you do too. I think it would help both of you.
JoJo
I like your response. I would agree that the drama of the grandfather in the hospital might have been too much for an already emotionally fragile kid. People act crazily when their parents are ill, I speak from personal experience with my grandmother's passing last year. My mom and Aunt literally were fist fighting over what was best for grandma. SD was probably best off remembering him as she does, not ill and weak.
It is best to let her grieve on her own terms. I like the taking her to the grave when she is ready.
Diva....
I can tell u from experience that 14 was the worst age for me with my skids accepting some of the things that they found out abour their BM....so....and with her borderline issues, imo, u did the absolute right thing....it appears that yur SD is starting to "heal" to some degree, thanks to YOU....and listen....if BM made those sexual molestation accusations about the man....who WOULD push a 14yr old girl with some issues to go see him on his deathbed? I agree....let her say her goodbyes at the gravesite if she so chooses....I can tell u....my skids want nothing to do with BM and her family (of course the abuse here was extreme) and I would NEVER influence any one of them to interact with any one of them on any level that they did not feel comfortable about...God will judge me...I am fine with that :)...I think u did the right thing for yur SD....now drop that baggage in the dumpster
"You can catch more flies with honey than you can with vinegar"
with great ability to manipulate...
comes great power...
If you are a stable person, I am sure you used your power for good.
Maybe next time you "know" you can "sway" something that may come back to make you look bad....run!
I have the same inner conflicts all the time and I really have to watch myself. (Emotional integrity)
Evil Diva!! A kindred spirit!
I cannot express to you how much your blog resonates with me... I truly struggle with the same things over here with SD as well.
My SD is suffering from depression and is in therapy. But whenever she asks a question, I pretty much tell her the truth. And she has a horrible relationship as well with her mother.
I worry, that I am actually guilty of Parental Alienation Syndrome against the mom... but, like you, it seems, I don't think it helps her to completely hide the truth.
Rest assured Diva that when I brought this up to Stepdaughter's counselor, the counselor has let me know that it is "fine". There has been some points where the counselor says, try to stay neutral as much as possible, which means acknowledge SD's anger, without feeding it or dismissing it. It is very difficult to do and I struggle with that (both when I agree and disagree with SD on why.)
You sound like you are fair. So I"m guessing that when BM warrants some positive spin, you give it as best you can? I'm also guessing you don't completely bash the woman - you just give the facts.
Over here, we give the facts to SD. Sometimes in order to stay neutral, we'll give both sides of those facts just so that SD can understand how to look at something from two angles. I will say to her.... well, this is what happened, this is why I feel one way, and your mom probably feels, or has indicated she feels this way. Then, I leave it up to her to decide what she thinks is correct.
I have been through this so much and struggle with it. But I think you are doing the right thing.
And, as long as you keep questioning yourself like you did above.... I'm positive you are doing the right thing!!
Best of luck to you. I thought the suggestion from JoJo to take your SD to the cemetery privately was a wonderful idea.
*** A rainbow just threw up on me... and now I'm sh*tting glitter! ***