You are here

Stepparent or Coparent?

SKIDRow's picture

I was engaged to a wonderful man who has sole custody of his 10 year old son. We connected, immediately fell in love and he asked me to move in with him, we got engaged immediately. We could talk about anything, and never really argued about anything ( but his son). His son initially was excited, but soon he became pretty passive aggressively disrespectful. It was clear his father and I did not agree on rules, structure or actions and consequences. Fast forward 2 years later, we pressed forward and we planned a wedding and I allowed him to convince me that the issue was that I was overly critical of his son, because we did not have any children of our own. I never directly addressed his son, I always expected FI to handle the issue ( he never did), or he and SS would secretly chat, which usually ended in laughter and wrestling...but the behavior never changed.
I have a BS who was 19 and did not live in the home with us. FI convinced me that I had the empty nest syndrome and was substituting my "mothering" instinct on his son, which was not needed. Although his son was ungrateful, mannerless, messy, and would only listen to his Dad... his father felt like I demanded too much of him. They'd lived as bachelors, with loose rules for years and that I'd expected too much too soon. He said if I just disengaged, and allowed him to be the leader that things would be fine. He wanted me to contribute financially, cook, clean, support school and sporting events, but have no say in how his son treated our home. I tried..I failed and needless to say we ended up cancelling a wedding 6wks prior (lost $15K). I moved out of the home only to find out that we were expecting a child. TIMING SUCKED!! So now for the sake of this child we are trying couples counseling to determine if this is worth saving. My struggle is this....I'm actually happier now. I'm at peace, I enjoy coming home and I enjoy us each having our own space. I enjoy not having to deal with his son, or the deadbeat BM. The problem is that I do miss the man he is ( when he's not being "daddy") we are still very much in love but any mention of his son still leaves us figuratively scratching each other eyeballs out. Even living apart our arguments over his son are vicious, nothing has changed.He still wants me to be the silent partner. During our last counseling session we argued so much that our counselor suggested we take a couple weeks of zero contact to determine if this is worth fighting for. So....everything I'm reading says RUN, but with our new Biobaby on the way I'm not sure what to do. Since we have to deal with each other for the next 18 years am I really escaping anything?? Am I getting the better deal hanging in there marrying the man and toughing out stepparenting for the next 6 yrs, or should I run now and just co-parent with our Biobaby,and find someone else to marry.

AllySkoo's picture

SO tough to say! For now anyway, absolutely do not marry him. You're happier living alone than with him - that says a lot.

The other thins you need to do is COMPLETELY disengage from his son. You do not go to sporting events, you do not cook or clean for him, you don't make him eat his veggies or go to bed at a reasonable hour, you DO NOT babysit. In fact, at this point, I'd go "no contact" with the kid for as long as you can. Don't even discuss him. Date your FI, live apart, don't discuss his kid for now, and see where things go. Revisit in 6 months and see if you can even talk about it without arguing. Honestly, I'd stay completely disengaged from the kid even if you got married and moved into the house again. Not your child, not your problem. And if Dear Old Dad wants you to engage with his child, the answer is "no, not until there are some changes FROM YOU".

ChiefGrownup's picture

This man did you a tremendous disservice by convincing you it was all in your head. Only you know what kind of man he really is, if he had no idea he was actually in the wrong or if he's a practiced manipulator.

For this conversation I will assume he is a good man but misguided. So if you marry him, you will be a vulnerable pregnant woman living with a jealous and coddled boy (12? 10?) who has few if any limits and boundaries. Your pregnancy will be about this boy's insecurity and jealousy. There will be constant tension, the same you've already experienced, but ramped up dramatically as kid senses a new threat (baby).

On the other hand, if you don't marry him, once the baby is born, you will have NO SAY WHATSOEVER about what happens when your baby is at Dad and big bro's house. Dad will trust big bro in ways you never would and you won't be there to snatch your baby up and out of reach.

You are in a tight spot.

The best possible thing would be if you and this man could learn to discuss differences in a peaceful and constructive way first. Then if you can master that, hopefully you can make some headway with his parenting. The counseling is a good start.

But you need your own boundaries repaired. Don't let him gaslight you again, even unintentionally. Part of any agreement of you moving back in is the stated rule that you are an adult in your own home, not a "silent partner" (whatever the hell that's supposed to be in a marriage). You would have rules for any neighbor kid who wandered in, you can not be hog-tied in relation to the boy who lives there. No marriage can work if both partners are not treated as full adults.

SKIDRow's picture

Thanks for the advice @allyskoo when I lived with him I tried to disengage which eventually led to problems with FI. He was so unhappy about my disengaging, he did not try to find a way to draw us closer together, it instead drew him closer to his son (a.k.a mini-wife). They cooked together, spent time together, went to movies, sporting events. It's like he replaced me with is son, so there was nothing that I was really doing for him but sex..and when I stopped that. Our relationship completely fell apart...thus cancelling our wedding because we hadn't talked for weeks, and hadn't had sex for months.
We tried dating after I moved out, and during the pregnancy but it's been disappointing because as a single dad, by the time he gets off of work, cook dinner, complete homework it's the after 10pm, and the next day rinse and repeat. Weekends are reserved for little league sports and his 2nd job. No time left for me. FI has no support with his son here, and BM is a loser so he never has a babysitter or anywhere for his kid to go. So this pregnancy has been very much alone. Only 2 more months left and I feel like since I've been so alone and unsupported...I'm not sure I could forgive him. How much more vulnerable can I be right now, and he's still coddling his son.
@ChiefGrownup your advice is spot on, and reminds me how much I hate my life...this feels like such a no win situation. I'd like to think that he's a good guy, who is being an ass. But since he's acted like an ass so long I'm starting to think he's just an asshole (towards me anyway). The idea of him and his mini-wife(SS)raising this child EOW makes me want to scream but you're right I wont have any control. He's immovable on the "silent-partner" issue. Nothing has convinced this man to change his mind, not a cancelled wedding, not my moving out, not breaking up, not even the idea of having to pay child support..he's convinced since BM is a piece of shit, his son is fragile & he wont disturb his son's world. At the end of our zero contact time, I need to make a decision.

This is so hard to accept. I HATE MY LIFE RIGHT NOW!!! I AM SO TRAPPED. Sad