You are here

OT (sort of) - Has MIL gone off the deep end?

strugglingSM's picture

Continuing the MIL saga, after MIL invited herself to join DH on his weekend away with SSs, DH took a moment to tell MIL how hurt he was that MIL insisted upon meddling with BM and how he feels like he can't trust her. He told her that he feels like she always just makes excuses and doesn't take responsiblity or apologize. This is the second time DH has told MIL how hurt he was. Instead of apologizing, MIL just told DH that he was being unreasonable and people make mistakes and he needs to move on. So, he leaves it at that and he and I both talk about how MIL will not likely change. How he's told her how he feels and still doesn't get support, so he's ready to accept that. 

So, building on that, DH and I had some good news to share with MIL and her reaction, while positive, was completely outsized. It involved extended tears and blubbering. I asked DH if he thought she had been drinking, because she was just way over the top, but it was in the middle of the day. 

A week later, DH goes to help MIL move some furniture. She had rented a pick-up truck from UHAUL. Upon arrival at UHAUL, DH says to her, "Mom, I won't be able to get the furniture into the pickup truck. It's too high. Could we switch to a box truck, which is the same price?" MIL starts getting teary and says, "I can never do anything right with you!" DH says, "Mom, I'm just telling you that it will be impossible for me to lift the furniture up over the tailgate, because it's too high." As they were driving back in the truck, DH pointed out to MIL that she is often critical of him and he doesn't understand why. MIL pushes DH again to go to counseling with her (she pushed for this when she got caught meddling). DH replies, "Mom, I don't think you are going to change and counseling will only work if we are both open to changing how we interact with one another." MIL replies, "me, change? I think the counselor would tell you how you need to change!" Oh, MIL, apparently you have never been to counseling. DH then says, "mom, this is the point where you say something hurtful to me and I react like an angry teenager and then you feel justified in how you feel about me." Again, I asked DH if he thought his mother had been drinking because her teary reaction to his suggestion that they rent a different truck is not a normal reaction. 

MIL has such a weird relationship with DH. She is constantly shaming him and setting him up for no-win situations with his children and BM through her meddling. She also acts like he's a total non-entity and uses him as her emotional outlet. He was the one who was expected to move back home and support her after FIL died (even though she was financially stable and BIL and SIL were both adults, so not sure why she needed his help) and he did that without complaint. He is always helping her, as opposed to BIL who promises the world, but is completely unreliable. Yet, BIL is the golden child for MIL, he can do no wrong. DH will never measure up and I will always be secondary to silent SIL. 

I'm honestly proud of DH for speaking up to MIL, but man it is exhausting dealing with a needy, childish, dysfunctional adult. MIL often asks DH why I don't call her on the phone, but really, why would I? She's lucky that I am willing to see her ever outside of major holidays. I was hoping that COVID-19 would keep her from coming back from her wintering in Florida for the entire year, but sadly, it did not. 

Comments

advice.only2's picture

Wow your MIL sounds like my mother. Difference is I know my mother does not drink, when she does the whole teary eyed thing it's because in her mind she believes she is just trying to teach me how to be a better person by criticizing everything I do. Or reminding me endlessly of things I did when I was younger, I love having my youth thrown back in my face all the time.

I have learned I can't talk to my mom, not when it comes to her behavior or how she acts. Instead I have learned to ignore the behavior and not give her the opening she wants to criticize me, my DH and my children. So instead we have a very superficial relationship and I don't interact with her much anymore. The sad byproduct is I don't interact with my father much anymore either because he wants me to deal with her so she will leave him alone and I have stopped doing that.

strugglingSM's picture

DH mostly has a superficial relationship with his mother, because he is a peacemaker and is also conflict avoidant. I have a problem with her constant shaming though, especially since I'm also often shamed by association. She's also big on gaslighting and trying to convince me that I'm wrong about things, particularly silent SIL (when I told MIL that I couldn't work out plans with SIL because she had only acknowledged my presence once in five years, MIL told me I was mistaken and SIL was just a "bad communicator") and BM (who MIL argues is always justified in her terrible behavior, because she is just looking out for the children, as opposed to DH). MIL is all about appearances, which means she will sweep any dysfunctional behavior under the rug. She used to reach out to me to try to make sure that I wasn't offended by her behavior toward DH or her meddling with BM. I would sometimes try to share information with her about what DH's experience looked like, but I've now given up and just try to avoid her. She knows that DH and I went to premarital counseling largely due to BM who went absolutely crazy after we got engaged (even though she was already remarried when I met DH), but she still tries to justify BM's behavior to me, so my ears now close every time MIL stops talking. I'm also sick of feeling like my role is to validate MIL, because really, do I need to be emotionally validating another adult...especially one who only creates more obligations for me, without any support in return? No, I don't have time for any of that. If she was not DH's mother, I would have cut her off long ago. 

Findthemiddle's picture

Tough and annoying situation- only thing I can think of is to be superficially polite, spend as little time with her as possible, and learn how to politely change the topic when she yammers on.