PAS' ing
Forums:
Do you all really believe that there are that many cases of PAS? It seems to be a go to answer here.
As a BM, I know I'm not PAS'ing my kid, her Counselor says I'm not, her Dad says I am. I can 100% guarantee that my children's Father's GF would NEVER say what she has done to inspire hatred from my adolescent daughter.
I recognize that it happens but I think less then people assume.
***
***
The term PAS has become over
The term PAS has become over used just like the word bully.
My step sister was pas'd by
My step sister was pas'd by her mom 30 years ago. I have only met her 2 times. We were young and could have been friends. My SF wasn't perfect but didn't and still doesn't deserve the treatment he got. His ex really thought she was all innocent and protecting her "baby" barf. My siblings and I turned out awful with good jobs and caring SOs. SF had a lot to do with it because our dad died. It sickens me that BMs could do that to a child and I think there is a lot of pas'sing happening either for spite or unconsciously.
I think it is very common. I
I think it is very common. I know in our case we have never said a bad word against BM to SS, but she has gone out of her way to demean us in any way possible, even recently telling SS that she left DH because he was a 'sex-crazed fuckup'. Who says that to a child about their father? (not true also!)
My ex really does PAS my
My ex really does PAS my daughter against me. He says shit like "I'm so disappointed in you, you're becoming just like your mother" or "Your mother has been irresponsible and foolish her entire life, what makes you want to be like her" or "Your mother is worthless, why do you even want to be around her?"
And we know for a fact that BM is poisoning SD14's mind against DH. A few of SD's words were definitely BM's DH has said. And she claims BM is just a saint and would never do anything harmful to her or allow her to engage in any type of risky behavior because she just loves her too much. HA! That's why SD ended up having sex at BM's house while BM was at work at age 13...and BM allows SD to take her phone to bed with her every night so SD got busted sexting her boyfriend and having him meet her in her yard so she could give him head? Yeah, sure, BM would never harm you, SD! She's an amazing mother.
PAS is real and it's been
PAS is real and it's been going on for a long time. Naming it as "PAS" is a recent phenomenon, though.
OP, how do you KNOW you are not doing it to your child? You say your counselor agrees you don't - Is that based on what you've told counselor or what the kids have told counselor?
What has your DH's girlfriend done to inspire hatred from your adolescent daughter?
Not saying it can't happen but you seem to be on-board and (maybe?) egging your daughter on in her justificationn for "hating" her dad's GF?
(Adolescents, by the way, are all known to be drama-free, never exaggerate and never hate anyone without a lot of justification!)
Of course, since you are posting as a BM and not a SM, answers will be provided from differing perspectives.
Yes. I believe PAS is real
Yes. I believe PAS is real and it can be subtle or direct.
If the parents hate each other, PAS is sometimes difficult to avoid. PAS finds its roots in that animosity. It's easy to classify PAS as subtle (ie. "Oh my goodness you are shivering! Didn't your Dad give you a sweater? I would never let you venture out in the cold without a sweater!" or direct (i.e. "Your Dad lost his job because he's an idiot!").
PAS is like a combat maneuver and like combat maneuvers there are an endless combination of direct and indirect moves that can be made to PAS a child. The end result runs the risk of completely shutting out a child emotionally from the other parent.
I also believe that PAS is a knee-jerk reaction. A statement said in a moment of anger could result in PAS even if the end goal was to never alienate the child from the other parent. Children are like emotional sponges and they quickly learn to adopt a parent's feelings towards some people; be it another parent, grandparent, cousin, neighbor, friends, etc.
Okay, the GF issues... My ex
Okay, the GF issues... My ex was remarried when I met my husband but my ex, his wife & I were contemplating a move (military), when the orders came in that the twilight tour would be here, no moves, my new husband & I solidified our relationship. We had been dating 5 months but hadn't met each other's kids, etc. After another month, we introduced our kids & 5 months later, we got married. My ex proceeded to tell our children we had moved too fast, that you should know each other 6 months before introducing your kids, etc. Keep in mind that he met his 2nd wife on a Thursday, she & her son spent the night Friday & met our daughters on Saturday. As all of his badmouthing was occurring, he filed for divorce from his 2nd wife & our daughters took this horribly, we put them back into counseling. 2 months after filing for divorce, my ex met his GF. Overnight stays started immediately, the kids expressed their dissatisfaction to their Dad & the Counselor (keep in mind, they moved pursuant to his 2nd divorce). He was told to back it up, he was moving too rapidly, etc but refused to listen to the Mediator's advice. He moved in permanently & our daughters turned on him, using his "too soon" argument ON HIM. GF thinks its me, GF has called me to yell at me about this & yes, I did say that I felt it was awfully quick since he had JUST FILED for divorce. It hit the fan, she didn't know about wife #2. Our daughters had been sworn to secrecy & yes, 1 is acting out & pushing the new GF's buttons & yes, hates new GF's kids but new GF should never have told a young girl "you're a little b----, just like your Mother" or told her "shut the f--- up" or given her the middle finger. My ex does nothing to deal with any of this & obviously has misled this woman a few times.
My opinion on the GF is that she's misled but my ex won't permit her to go to a counseling session, I assume because he doesn't want the kids telling this woman the truth about many things. I think she has behaved inappropriately, irregardless of what the child did, & if she was a friend's Mother, I would keep my kid away. I blame my ex though, this woman has money & he likes her lifestyle, he won't stand up for our child or tell his GF the truth, until caught.
This isn't PAS.
After having been through this, I'm inclined to believe that not everything is PAS & that sometimes people aren't totally honest & forthcoming, thus causing friction with children.
As a SM, I have nada to do with BM & I like that.
"I'm inclined to believe that
"I'm inclined to believe that not everything is PAS & that sometimes people aren't totally honest & forthcoming"
I think whenever you hear one person's story, you're hearing ONE side of a much more complex monster. I never make the assumption that we're hearing 100% of anything on this site .. it's just impossible to get all perspectives/motives/intentions/etc.
I think PAS is very real .. and I think sometimes it happens without people even realizing it.
Just like .. kids can grow up to be racist or sexist or homophobic or whatever just becasue of what they're EXPOSED to in their homes. Parents don't need to explicitly say gay people are bad .. but kids still learn it. I don't see how this is any different when it comes to a parent and PAS.
That being said, now that it has a name .. "PAS" .. it's bad and identifiable and something to treat. So yeah, I think that leads to over-diagnosis ..
>It hit the fan, she didn't
>It hit the fan, she didn't know about wife #2. <
ROTFLMAO!!!!
Stepmomma, I'm not justifying
Stepmomma, I'm not justifying anything, I'm NOT talking bad about my ex or his GF. He preached to our kids about "not rushing" & it bit him in the butt because our kids used that argument ON HIM. I'm saying that my ex & his GF think I'm engaging in PAS but the GF has no clue what is really going on in these kids's heads, not knowing what he told them previously or about his relationships post-divorce with me.
I get Draco's point about saying things "off the cuff" so to say, not all out war but saying an occasional inappropriate thing. Thats a fact of life, it happens & it is only through recognizing your inappropriate actions or words & remedying the situation that we grow (& teach our children to be good people who seek to do the right thing). However that is hardly Parental Alienation SYNDROME. A syndrome is defined as a "group" of signs/symptoms. I stand by my belief that we all make mistakes but that PAS requires doing these wrong things repeatedly, not the occasional flub.
I had no idea what PAS was or
I had no idea what PAS was or how bad it could be until I married my DH three years ago, and watched how his ex behaved. She has been in therapy for 20 years. We agree that her diagnosis is most likely BPD. She hates my DH with a deep and abiding passion, and first tried to bar DH from visitation with a false restraining order. When this was thrown out of court, she did her best to wreck our marriage by dumping SD, then 12, on us a few months later. Literally told DH "Don't bring her back" when we picked the child up for a weekend. But we managed for almost 2 years to give the child a normal life, and I am proud of our success, and the progress SD made academically and socially. BM couldn't stand it, so she began her campaign to alienate SD, which has resulted in SD returning to live with her mother, and DH having only a weekly phone call for contact with his child. So, IMHO, PAS is real, it can be devastating, and normal people don't do it. I never saw anything like it with any divorced couple I ever knew before. But this website has a large number of step-parents who are dealing with high conflict situations, with constant litigation, and crazy behavior by the ex. Statistics show most litigation in divorces and custody situations is fueled by personality disordered people. If you have the bad luck to get in the middle of such a situation, you are totally unprepared for the venom and hatred of one person toward another, and it seems unreal and it is really tragic for the child. My SD is now in an alternative school, which she does not need, and has become socially isolated, and is back to being dressed in Goodwill and yard sale clothes. She could have had a normal high school life, but her mother had to take her in order to hurt my DH. Her daughter is just another weapon to use to express her hate.
Many parents BOTH Moms and
Many parents BOTH Moms and Dads do engage in PAS behavior. Sadly, most don't realize it however.
I was 15 when my parents got divorced and they BOTH did it. My Dad would speak horribly about my Mom and my Mom constantly bashed my Dad. They both attempted to alienate me and my Brothers from the other and turn us against each other. So, yes I do believe in it because I experienced it myself. Both of my parents DENY it!!
DH and I NEVER say ONE word about BM's around either of my SD's, EVER. We don't bring them up at all. If SD's mention their BM's we either ignore the comment or kindly respond with a positive reinforcement, like "That's really neat." "Good for your Mom." etc etc
HOWEVER, both BM's in my case constantly tell SD's stories about DH, dig up the past, make hateful remarks and are bitter, angry and jealous.
If you make negative remarks around your children about their Father, that IS a form of alienation and PAS.
I think this sort of behavior
I think this sort of behavior occurs very very frequently. I do believe, like anything else, it is on a continuum-to very severe to very mild. I will tell you right now I have made PAS sorts of statements to my ss in the past-not severe ones, but rather mild ones. My dh has, My bm has. Lots of people do.
To identify it as acutal PAS-in terms of the syndrome I think there needs to be a pervasive pattern of this behavior not an occassional comment here or there. My former sd was PASed horribly by her mother growing up-old school, before PAS was considered as a syndrome. She was literally told, your father ruined our lives, he cheated on me (he actually didnt and certainly not with me), your father caused me to have a nervous breakdown, he is evil-all the way to I believe your father molested you-when he and I got together she was told, "he loves her more than you, he will ignore you now that she is around, she will be jealous of you, she will hate you," and so on and so on. To the point, where as a teen this girl did not even feel "comfortable" living with us. She would point blank say, "I dont know why I feel this way, I just feel like I'm supposed to be with my mom". I think there is more press about it now, it is more recognized and hopefully that will decrease its occurrence-but as i said I think it occurs on a subtle level quite frequently.
Okay, it seems like many
Okay, it seems like many people understand my point, that not EVERYTHING is PAS, it may just be occasional bad comments. I understand actual PAS & yes, think it happens but I read posts here & see comments of "BM is PAS'ing the skids" & at times, with very little other supporting evidence, that seems like a major stretch.
I have taught my children that smoking is bad & nasty, that people who smoke have the smell lingering & that damaging their lungs will hurt their athletic opportunities. My children know I don't want them in a smoker's household & that those friends can come to our house. My ex always did this too. We grew up with parents who smoked & we hate it. New GF smokes. THIS is the type of thing that he now says is PAS. It isn't, its teaching my beliefs to my children. My son has a friend whose parents do not allow him to watch the Indiana Jones movies citing the evil undertones & how it conflicts with their religious views... The kid makes it sound bad but in reality, he's listening to his parents & standing up for the values they share as a family, even when at other people's homes. I had another kid describe to me the evils of pork & why she wasn't eating a S'more unless I could give her a Vegan marshmallow.
I am thoroughly convinced that some of these "thats PAS" statements are because we don't know the OTHER parent & their value set. Also, those value sets changed as we grow & mature, gain more experience. My ex is now okay with smoking, both my ex & I valued virginity when we got married, now we know that was why we got married so young & are not placing an emphasis on that. I am not advocating round table meetings, hand holding, chanting & Chai tea drinking together but maybe what comes across from a kid as condemnation is just misunderstanding. This ofcourse goes out the window when phrased as "Mom says you're a whore who ruined our lives' but food, clothing, etc may be different value sets.